Waterproof: 8/10 (don't worry, I'm thinking full on sailor boots for 10/10)
My main goal was lightweight waterproof shoes, this fills that goal. But I've been having calf pains after a week of wearing these. I don't know if it's because the shoe is bit slippery inside, and my calves are getting extra exercise. The shoe is bit wider than normal, and even though I got half size small, I feel my heel slipping.
I'll probably replace the soles with custom ones, hopefully that would relieve my calf pains.